10 - sutherland
USING ENZYMES TO CLEAN UP PESTICIDE RESIDUES
Tara Sutherland and Robyn Russell from CSIRO Entomology in Canberra, Australia, and Michael Selleck ofOrica Australia Pty Ltd. describe exciting work being done on the use of enzymes to clean up pesticideresidues
Current research focuses on several major insecticide classes
Increasing pesticide use in recent years has led to public
including organophosphates, carbamates, synthetic pyre-
concern about the social and environmental impacts of
throids and the organochlorine, endosulfan.
pesticide residues. Of particular concern is the contamina-tion of irrigation run-off and drainage water, agriculturalsoils and horticultural products.
Detoxification of pesticide residues in contaminated soil
The team has isolated a soil microorganism (an Agrobac-
has been achieved by introducing, and/or encouraging, the
) that utilises organophosphate compounds as
growth of microorganisms that are capable of detoxifying
nutrient sources and detoxifies them. The organophosphate-
the residues on site – a technology known as bioremediation
degrading enzyme isolated from this bacterium attacks the
(detoxification using biological material). A well-known
phosphoester bond of aromatic oxon and thion organophos-
example of this is the clean up of petrochemical contami-
phates, but does not have activity against the aliphatic
nated Olympic sites in Sydney. This method of bioremedia-
versions of these compounds. However, protein engineering
tion is based on traditional composting techniques and relies
technologies have been employed to create a synthetic
on microbial growth to metabolise the toxicants. The detox-
variant of this enzyme that also degrades the aliphatic
ification process is generally slow, taking weeks to months
compounds. Collectively, the original enzyme and variants
to accomplish. Furthermore, the methodology is not suited
are predicted to degrade 90% of registered organophos-
to the generally low aeration, low nutrient state of contami-
The performance of the original enzyme for decontami-
However, the microorganisms that break down toxicants
nating organophosphates has been evaluated in several field
in contaminated soil can be sources of enzymes that will
trials. In the first field trial, methyl parathion levels in
detoxify pesticide residues in such situations. The applic-
80,000 L of fast flowing run-off water in cotton farm
ation of these enzymes is particularly suited to pesticide-
drainage channels were reduced by 90% in less than ten
contaminated water as they can achieve rapid remediation
minutes. This is a low concentration/high volume source of
without the addition of nutrients or aeration.
The problem of pesticide contamination of irrigation
water must be resolved before it can be released into water-ways. CSIRO Entomology, in conjunction with members ofthe Advanced Water Technologies business of OricaAustralia Pty Ltd. and CSIRO Molecular Sciences, hassuccessfully developed enzyme-based bioremediation tech-nologies for detoxifying pesticides in contaminated water.
This technology is being extended to the clean up of pesticidespills, the clean up of rinsings from spray equipmentwashdown, and for treatment of horticultural produce.
The search for such enzymes can be divided into four
source of enzyme is identified in bacteria or from other
the gene encoding the enzyme is identified and isolated the enzyme is cloned into a common bacterium, such as
Figure 1. Assembly of the enzyme dosing and mixing system.
Foreground: Orica employees Michael Selleck (left) and
the enzyme is produced by industrial-scale fermentation of
Andrew Dowd (right) lock the static mixer elements into
the E. coli
. Once there is a sufficient volume, the E. coli
place. Following assembly, the unit was lowered into the drop
box and inserted into the culvert. Background: Pipe work for
killed off, the enzymes which have been produced by the
the enzyme dosing system which was used to transfer and
bacterium are collected and applied to the contaminated
inject the dilute enzyme solution to the entry point to the
This journal is The Royal Society of Chemistry 2002
soil. In contrast to the organophosphate degradingbacterium, which has the ability to degrade many differentorganophosphates, this bacterium has a narrow substraterange and does not detoxify other carbamate pesticides.
However, the enzyme that is responsible for this activity isstable under a variety of conditions, does not require any co-factors for activity and results in substantial detoxificationof carbaryl, a pesticide used worldwide on horticulturalproduce. CSIRO Entomology will use protein engineeringtechnologies in an attempt to increase the substrate range ofthis enzyme so that it can be used to detoxify othercarbamate compounds.
Another hydrolase enzyme with potential for use in biore-
mediation has been isolated from insects that are resistant to
certain pesticides. Protein technologies have again been
employed to design variants of this enzyme that can degrade
pyrethroid insecticides. These enzymes are stable against a
range of biotic and abiotic challenges (e.g.
extremes of pH
and temperature, and bacterial protease digestion) with half-
lives in some agricultural waste streams of a number of
days. These enzymes can be produced on a large scale in
bacteria using fermentation techniques, and they are being
trialed for commercial use in the detoxification of pyrethroid
Figure 2. Preparation of the dilute enzyme solution. Orica
employee, Michael Selleck, mixing in 8 l of enzyme
The CSIRO Entomology team has also isolated bacteria that
concentrate with 172 l of a buffer solution. The 180 l of dilute
degrade the two isomers of endosulfan and the toxic
enzyme solution was subsequently used to treat 80,000 l of
metabolite of endosulfan, endosulfan sulfate. These bacteria
were isolated by providing endosulfan, as the only source ofsulfur, to a soil microbial population. Sulfur is an essential
pesticide-contaminated water, that also contains high levelsof silt and other particulate matter. In a second field trialconducted at the Victorian Department of Natural Resourcesand Environment, Tatura, enzyme treatment of rinsate fromthe washdown of pesticide spray equipment achieved areduction in methyl parathion concentration of 90% in 10minutes, and 99% after 1 hour. In contrast to the run-offwater in the first trial, rinsate is a high concentration/lowvolume source, which also contains organic solvents.
Other applications of enzyme technology are also being
investigated. One application with considerable potential isthe treatment of used sheep dip liquor, which contains theorganophosphate diazinon. Laboratory studies have providedproof of concept and planning for a field trial is in progress. Asecond application concerns the treatment of permethrincontaining effluent from the wool dyeing operations.
Laboratory studies aimed at establishing proof of concept
are underway. Enzymes also have the potential to help in
Figure 3. Treatment of irrigation run-off water. A small volume
decontamination of polluted soils where they could be used
of the run-off water leaving the field was pumped out of the
in solutions applied directly to damp soil.
drop box by a submersible pump (lower left). To this volume,
the dilute enzyme solution was dosed proportionally and pre-
mixed prior to being injected into the bulk of the run-off
water via the injection line (vertical pipe, centre). The static
mixer that was previously inserted into the culvert provided
A bacterium that degrades the carbamate insecticide,
brief, but intense mixing of the injected enzyme/run-off mix
carbaryl, has been isolated from carbamate-contaminated
with the bulk of the run-off.
component of living matter. Therefore only the bacteria that
Lyndall Briggs, Erica Crone, Sue Dorrian, Robyn Russell
could release the sulfur from endosulfan could survive.
and John Oakeshott (CSIRO Entomology); Michael Selleck,
Removal of sulfur from either endosulfan or endosulfan sulfate
Mel Costello and Hung Nguyen (Orica Australia Pty Ltd);
results in substantial detoxification of these compounds. The
Geoff Dumsday and Michael Zachariou (CSIRO Molecular
enzymes responsible for this activity are monooxygenases.
Science) and is funded by Horticulture Australia Limited,
They differ from the hydrolase enzymes described above in
Cotton Research and Development Corporation, Australian
requiring co-factors for activity. CSIRO and Orica Australia
Cotton CRC, CRC for Sustainable Rice Production and
are currently investigating the use of these systems for biore-
Orica Australia Ltd. Orica also wishes to thank the
Victorian Department of Natural Resources andEnvironment (NRE), Tatura, for hosting the latest field trial.
Contacts: Robyn Russell, CSIRO Entomology Ph 02 6246 4
Commercialisation of the enzymatic bioremediation
Fax 02 6246 4 Email [email protected]
technology could involve three types of products.
Michael Selleck, Orica Australia Pty Ltd Ph 03 9283 6342
A freeze-dried enzyme powder for treatment of contami-
Fax 03 9283 6266 Email [email protected]
nated water. This will have a shelf life of several monthsand will be reconstituted prior to application to the conta-
Russell, R. J.; Harcourt, R. L.; Oakeshott, J. G. (1998). Bioremedi-
A polyurethane pad containing immobilised enzymes.
ation of pesticides using enzymes. In ACIAR Proceedings No.
Prototypes of this product have proven effective for
85: Seeking Agricultural Produce Free of Pesticide Residues
soaking up and decontaminating pesticide spills and
R. Kennedy, J. H. Skerritt, G. I. Johnson and E. Highley (eds),
wiping down spraying equipment.
Russell, R. J.; Harcourt, R.; Sutherland, T.; Nguyen, H.;
A self-contained user-friendly device containing
Oakeshott, J. G. (1999) Can we clean water with microbes?
immobilised enzyme that will allow the detection of
pesticide residues at concentrations as low as 20 parts per
Russell, R. J., Sutherland, T. D., Horne, I., Oakeshott, J. G.,
billion is being developed.
Zachariou, M., Nguyen, H. V., Selleck, M. L.; Costello, M.
(2001) Enzymatic bioremediation of chemical pesticides.
Chemical pesticide usage is unlikely to decline substantially
in the near future, despite the development of transgeniccrops and other alternative biological controls. Environmentaland safety concerns are leading to increasingly stringentresidue requirements by regulatory authorities. Whilst theseconcerns are being addressed through better pesticide andwater management practices, there is an increasing need for
is currently doing a second post-doc in the Biopro-
rapid and effective remediation technologies in many
cessing and Enzymology section at CSIRO Entomology, Canberra,Australia, following post-doc work in Arizona, USA.
industrial and agricultural processes. The CSIRO-OricaAustralia joint initiative is developing biotechnologies to
, who has 23 years post-doctoral experience in
address this need.
molecular biology and biochemistry, leads the Bioprocessing andEnzymology project at CSIRO Entomology.
is a chemical engineer and molecular biologist, and
has spent the past two and a half years working on enzymatic
The research is being carried out by Tara Sutherland, Irene
bioremediation technology for Orica Australia Pty Ltd.
Horne, Kahli Weir, Christopher Coppin, Michelle Williams,
EVER THOUGHT OF WRITING AN ARTICLE FOR PESTICIDE OUTLOOK?
The Editor would welcome articles for Pesticide Outlook
. The aim of the journal is to publish readable up-to-date, interestingarticles for a wide audience, which should be understandable without any assumed specialist knowledge. They should have anintroduction, a few sections of information arranged to give a logical flow of argument, and end with a conclusion summing thingsup and pointing the way forward. Articles can range in length from 500-2000 words. Photographs, diagrams, tables etc.
arewelcomed to increase the visual appeal of the article.
Please note that contributions are refereed by two members of our Editorial Board and so publication is not guaranteed. A smallhonorarium is paid on publication.
Please send manuscripts to Hamish Kidd, Pesticide Outlook
, The Royal Society of Chemistry, Thomas Graham House, Science Park, Milton Road, Cambridge CB4 0WF. FAX +44 (0)1223 432160; email: [email protected]
DEPARTMENT OF PERIODONTOLOGY SNO. NAME THESIS TOPIC 1. Dr.Yogender Singh Evaluation And Comparison of Healing of Periodontal Interdisciplinary Periodontics (2013-2016) Flaps when Approximated with Silk Sutures and N- Butylcyanoacrylate: A Clinico- Histological Study
Cycling Poll, 2016 MARU/VCR&C via the Measuring Torontonians' interest in a Safer Cycling Network This research was commissioned by Evergreen in partnership with Cycle Toronto, Toronto Centre for Active Transportation, and the Metcalf Foundation. • Background & Methodology• Support for the "Safer Cycling Network"• Needs assessment: urgency for cycle infrastructure• Perceived Benefits: