Primary Task-specific Bowing Tremor:
An Entity of its Own?
Dr. med. André Lee, MD, and Prof. Dr. med. Eckart Altenmüller, MD, MA
A professional violinist in his early 60s, playing in a prestigious
or bradykinesia present. Cranial nerves were normal. No rest-
German orchestra for more than 20 years, presented to our institute
ing tremor was visible on either side. Smelling disorders were
because of a task-induced tremor in his right arm when playing the
violin. We describe the phenomenology of this tremor and its treat-
ment options and compare it to findings in primary writing tremor
Further diagnostic measures including a dopamine trans-
(PWT). We then discuss whether primary bowing tremor is an
porter (DAT) scan and a cerebral and cervical-spine MRI
entity of its own (similar to PWT) and propose hypotheses that
were unremarkable. Electrophysiological measures were
would derive from such a definition. Med Probl Perform Art 2012;
normal for motor evoked potentials (MEP) and marginally
prolonged for somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP).
In the family history, his father is reported to suffer from
either writer's cramp (WC) or primary writing tremor(PWT).
A male violinist in his early 60s had been playing the violin
When playing the violin, a pronation-supination tremor
for over 50 years, with more than 20 years in a professional
as well as a flexion-extension tremor in the wrist of about 7-
German orchestra. Tremor appeared first at the age of 46, in
8 Hz was visible and audible (Fig. 1), especially when playing
the right arm, while only playing the violin. Prior to this he
slow legato notes. Tremor was visible on all four strings of the
was involved in a car accident, resulting in a late arrival for a
violin equally and was most present between the middle and
concert where he had to play numerous, long-lasting, fast,
nut of the bow. No postural or resting tremor was visible.
and repetitive bowing-movements (16th notes) in a long-last-
When the left hand was used for bowing, no tremor
ing, romantic symphony. The following day he developed a
pain syndrome in the right shoulder. Subsequently, he rec-
Tremor appeared in everyday situations (e.g., filling a glass
ognized a progressive involuntary tremor of the right arm
of water) about 1.5 years ago, however to a lesser extent and
while playing the violin. From 2005 onward, he has received
unilateral as well.
medical treatment for continued pain syndromes in the mus-
Tremor initially responded to beta-blockers (propranolol
20 mg); however, this effect wore off over the course of 1 year.
In 2010, he presented to our institute for the first time
Alcohol still improves symptoms. Trihexiphenidyl treatment-
because of accelerated tremor progression for 1 year, which
did not lead to an improvement. Injections of botulinum
had caused him to reduce or cancel solo- or chamber music
toxin (Dysport®) were given twice and had a positive effect in
everyday life activities and some effect when playing the
Clinical neurological examination did not reveal any
violin, without side effects. The first injections were given to
pathologic findings. Reflexes were symmetrical without
the bicep, tricep, pronator teres, and supinator muscles. The
pathologic reflexes. No sensory deficit was detectable. Pal-
second injections were localized to the radial extensor carpi,
laesthesia was normal. Diadochokinesis was undisturbed.
radial flexor carpi, supinator, bicep, and tricep muscles.
There were no signs of cerebellar dysfunctions and no rigor
Treatment was not continued, because improvement at theviolin was insufficient.
Primidone (anticonvulsant) led to an improvement, but
Dr.med. Lee is Postdoctoral Research Fellow and Prof.Dr.med. Altenmüller
due to side effects (tiredness, slowing, and erectile dysfunc-
is Director at the University of Music, Drama and Media Hannover, and
tion), continuous treatment had to be stopped. He currently
the Institute for Music Physiology and Musicians' Medicine, Hannover,
takes primidone 75 mg prior to playing solos or chamber
music. Neither gabapentin nor topiramate (anticonvulsants)
Address correspondence to: Dr. André Lee, University of Music, Drama and
was effective. Clozapine was proposed, but so far not taken.
Media Hannover, Institute for Music Physiology and Musicians' Medicine,
Deep brain stimulation was declined by the patient.
Emmichplatz 1, 30175 Hannover, Germany. Tel +49 511 3100 552, fax
The patient continues to play in the orchestra and has
+49 51 3100 557. [email protected]
again started to perform chamber music concerts, however
2012 Science & Medicine. www.sciandmed.com/mppa.
less frequently than before tremor onset.
Medical Problems of Performing Artists
Tremor spread to other tasks about 14 years after onset of
primary bowing tremor. However, this did not affect hiseveryday life, and tremor at the violin remained the mostprominent and disturbing symptom. Tremor spreading toother tasks has been described in PWT before,4,11 and a stricttask-specificity was thus negated.10,11 Rather, an evolution ofthe disorder at different points in time11 was discussed.
Family history was positive, with the father suffering from
either WC or PWT. This alludes to a genetic component inbowing tremor that has been described in PWT.4,11
Environmental factors may play a role in primary bowing
tremor as well as in PWT. Bain et al.4 showed that 19% ofpatients with PWT had a previous history of trauma. Thiscorresponds to our patient, who had been involved in a caraccident with a subsequent pain syndrome of the right armprior to tremor onset.
Our treatment included botulinum toxin, which led to a
slight improvement. An improvement of tremor after botu-linum toxin injection also has been reported in PWT.12
Oral medications included propranolol, primidone,
gabapentin and trihexiphenidyl, of which most effective wereprimidone and propranolol. Trihexiphenidyl had a slight
Rectified EMG of the flexor carpi radialis (upper panel)
effect. This is in accordance with reports that about 33% of
and the extensor carpi radialis (lower panel) with a reciprocal activity
patients with PWT respond specifically to primidone or pro-
of about 7–8 Hz.
pranolol.4 Alcohol, which also has been reported to improvesymptoms in about 33% of PWT-patients,4 also relieved
tremor in our patient.
Tremor is defined as a rhythmical, oscillatory, and involun-
From a phenomenological point of view, our patient's symp-
tary movement of a body part1 and is one of the most
toms are very similar to those displayed in patients with
common movement disorders. Task-specific tremors have
PWT. Both tremors occur in a highly trained fine motor task.
been defined in the consensus statement on tremor in 1998.1
We therefore hypothesize that primary bowing tremor (PBT)
The most common task-specific tremor is PWT, which was
and PWT may share similar underlyingpathophysiological
first described by Rothwell in 1979.2 There are two types of
mechanisms so that PBT may be an entity of its own, as has
PWT: type A, which refers to tremor induced by writing, and
been proposed by Lederman13 (2010).
type B, which refers to tremor induced when holding the arm
The main pathophysiologic findings in PWT that corrob-
in the position for writing.2
orate the definitions of PWT as an entity of its own are:
It has since been an ongoing discussion, whether PWT is
a type of focal dystonia, a local form of essential tremor, or a
1. No excessive overflow in EMG recordings in PWT as opposed to
nosological entity of its own.1,3–6 Recent research suggests
that it is rather a separate entity.5–10
2. Normal reciprocal inhibition in PWT4,8 as compared to WC.14,153. In a recent study by Meunier et al.,16 TENS was shown to have a
Primary Bowing Tremor and PWT
deteriorative effect in PWT 6, whereas in WC high-frequencyTENS may be beneficial.
We report on a violinist in his early 60s, who presented to
4. Normal results for spinal and motor cortex excitability8 were
our institute because of a unilateral tremor. The tremor was
obtained in PWT, whereas it may be abnormal in essentialtremor and is abnormal in WC.17,18
present in the right arm and induced by playing the violin.
Age of onset was 46. He fulfilled the three criteria for focal
Defining PBT as an entity of its own, similar to PWT, has
task-specificity as described by Rosenbaum and Jankovic3: a)
the advantage in that it will allow a systematic approach to
tremor was unilateral and limited to one body part, i.e., the
new hypotheses concerning the pathophysiology of PBT:
right arm (focal); b) no other movement disorders were pres-ent; and c) tremor was at first provoked only by playing the
1. PBT shows no excessive overflow of EMG activity.
violin (task specific), corresponding to a type A tremor. It was
2. PBT show normal reciprocal inhibition.
mainly a pronation-supination tremor, similar to the move-
3. TENS does not have a beneficial effect on PBT.
ment described in PWT by Rothwell.2
4. PBT has a normal intracortical and spinal excitability.
December 2012 225
With regard to treatment options, we would hypothesize
10. Bain PG. Task-specific tremor. Handb Clin Neurol 2011; 100:711–718.
that thalamic stimulation may have a beneficial effect on PBT,
Ondo WG, Satija P. Task-specific writing tremor: clinical phenotypes,
as has been shown for PWT.19,20 Furthermore, brain imaging in
progression, treatment outcomes, and proposed nomenclature. Int JNeurosci 2012; 122(2):88-91. doi:10.3109/00207454.2011.630544.
PBT should reveal a distinct activation pattern similar to that in
12. Papapetropoulos S, Singer C. Treatment of primary writing tremor
PWT.7 Future research is needed to clarify these hypotheses.
with botulinum toxin type a injections: report of a case series. Clin Neu-ropharmacol 2006; 29:364–367.
13. Lederman RJ: The tremulous bow arm: technical or neurological? Pre-
sented at the 28th Annual Symposium of Medical Problems of Per-
1. Deuschl G, Bain P, Brin M. Consensus statement of the Movement
forming Artists, 2010, Aspen Colorado.
Disorder Society on Tremor. Ad Hoc Scientific Committee. Mov.
14. Nakashima K, et al. Reciprocal inhibition between forearm muscles in
Disord. 1998; 13 (suppl 3):2–23.
patients with writer's cramp and other occupational cramps, sympto-
2. Rothwell JC, Traub MM, Marsden CD. Primary writing tremor. J
matic hemidystonia and hemiparesis due to stroke. Brain 1989; 112 (pt
Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatr 1979; 42:1106–1114.
3. Rosenbaum F, Jankovic J. Focal task-specific tremor and dystonia: cat-
15. Panizza M, Lelli S, Nilsson J, Hallett M. H-reflex recovery curve and
egorization of occupational movement disorders. Neurology 1988;
reciprocal inhibition of H-reflex in different kinds of dystonia. Neurol-
ogy 1990; 40:824–828.
4. Bain PG, et al. Primary writing tremor. Brain 1995; 118(pt
16. Tinazzi M, et al. Effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation
on motor cortex excitability in writer's cramp: Neurophysiological and
5. Hai C, Yu-ping W, Hua W, Ying S. Advances in primary writing
clinical correlations. Move Disord 2006; 21:1908–1913.
tremor. Parkinsonism Relat Disord 2010; 16:561–565.
Ridding MC, Sheean G, Rothwell JC, et al. Changes in the balance
6. Meunier S, et al. TENS is harmful in primary writing tremor. Clin Neu-
between motor cortical excitation and inhibition in focal, task specific
rophysiol 2011; 122:171–175.
dystonia. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatr 1995; 59:493–498.
7. Berg D, Preibisch C, Hofmann E, Naumann M. Cerebral activation
18. Chen R, Wassermann EM, Caños M, Hallett M. Impaired inhibition
pattern in primary writing tremor. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatr 2000;
in writer's cramp during voluntary muscle activation. Neurology 1997;
8. Modugno N, et al. Neurophysiological investigations in patients with
19. Minguez-Castellanos A, et al. Primary writing tremor treated by
primary writing tremor. Mov Disord 2002; 17:1336–1340.
chronic thalamic stimulation. Mov Disord 1999; 14:1030–1033.
9. Espay AJ, Chen R. Primary writing tremor and writer's cramp: distinct
20. Racette BA, Dowling J, Randle J, Mink JW. Thalamic stimulation for
phenomenology, diverging pathophysiology. Clin Neurophysiol 2011;
primary writing tremor. J Neurol 2001; 248:380–382.
Medical Problems of Performing Artists
Apoptosis (2007) 12:969–977DOI 10.1007/s10495-007-0755-3 HIV protease inhibitors modulate apoptosis signaling in vitro andin vivo Stacey R. Vlahakis · Steffany A. L. Bennett ·Shawn N. Whitehead · Andrew D. Badley Published online: 9 February 2007 Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2007 Abstract HIV protease inhibitors are an integral part of
ADVANCES IN NEUROPSYCHIATRY Neuropsychiatry of the basal ganglia J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2002;72:12–21 This review aims to relate recent findings describing the parts of the basal ganglia closest to limbic role and neural connectivity of the basal ganglia to the structures and that are involved in cognitive and clinical neuropsychiatry of basal ganglia movement